Covid-19 accelerates boom in unrealistic university leadership courses
The temptation for business schools to ‘solve’ the Covid-19 threat to higher education by packaging management and leadership courses into online offerings is likely to prove disastrous for the university sector, says Andrew Kakabadse, Professor of Governance and Leadership at Henley Business School.
He continues: “Every piece of digital material becomes rigorously scripted, losing nuance and the opportunity for spontaneous discussion or debate. While it’s possible to incorporate entertaining video clips containing stories, cameos and nods to the realities of leadership, such learning is devoid of context.
“Our ongoing research into corporate leadership shows that whether choices are made by the CEO of Enron or Lehman Brothers, the reasons behind resulting scandals or corporate failures were already known by an assortment of staff and management before they happened.
“The real deficiencies in organisations are never found on the risk register. Many staff accurately predict the demise of their enterprise well before it happens, but the reasons are rarely discussed beforehand because of the dysfunctionality between leaders over complex issues that are too sensitive to openly raise.
“Decision-making cannot be learnt in a crowd, so how can online education help us understand and work through tense, known concerns which herald long-term and damaging consequences?
“Despite this we all continue to be inundated with invitations to join webinars, online seminars and other forms of virtual gathering to learn the skills that will make a real ‘difference’ to our lives.
“In line with this trend, a recent Gartner survey highlights the determination of Chief Finance Officers (CFOs) to make remote working a central feature of the employment landscape. In fact, of CFOs:
- 81% plan to have hourly workers adopt remote, flexible working
- 20% report reducing office technology spend as homeworking will substitute this.
“The same survey reports that of top executives:
- 60% have cut back on leadership events and offsite gatherings
- 58% have frozen hiring
- 58% have frozen travel and conference attendance.
“The new substitute for all of these challenges has become online learning and remote working.
“However, it is context that is the most important challenge for leaders, and this is completely different for each sector or company a student is working in. Issues vary from interpreting new situations, through to understanding problems and acting correctly to solve them.
“Learning online offers a false sense of security, while true education comes from discussion around individuals’ experiences, feelings, assumptions and reflection upon the actions they have or haven’t taken.
“While operating online may be well suited to a set of specific and clearly-defined tasks, it fails drastically for organisations that have to differentiate from their competition, showcase a competitive edge, and make a substantive difference for their clients.
“Highly competitive markets require leadership capabilities that are not catered for by online training or remote learning.
“The development of leadership and high-performing managers requires a deep appreciation of significant obstacles that must be overcome on a case-by-case basis. This in turn develops an individual’s ability to navigate through a host of misaligned interests, enabling them to pull an organisation together.
“Leadership demands that we enhance core behaviours, intellect and personal qualities, such as resilience, sensitivity and humility. Capability development is contextually determined. Each different circumstance requires an alternate combination of capabilities to deal with it.
“In contrast, online skills training offers little more than generic bundles of delivery modules. These packages quickly become indistinguishable from one another and the only competitive advantage available is a lowering of price.
“To be clear, remote working and the delivery of online skills training was always going to take hold in some form, regardless of the Covid-19 crisis. However, convenience, simplicity and pricing offers nothing towards becoming a better manager or leader.
“The UK’s business school offer was always facing a dramatic reappraisal in the wake of Brexit, but this process has been massively accelerated by Covid-19. The question is ‘where will the appropriate education for leaders and wealth creators be centred in a post-Europe Britain?’
“The solution, I believe, lies in the creation of up to four new UK business schools which will provide executive education beyond and outside of the current university system.
“In effect this fourth tier of education would be completely divorced from Britain’s traditional higher education model and emphasise value-generating leadership that puts the UK on a par with Harvard University.
“Leaders need to be guided, intellectually-stretched and coached towards thinking how enterprises can be steered through the challenges of the day.
“In the current climate there is a desperate need for practical wisdom, and definitely not a bundle of slides or self-proclaimed expert videos forcing their way onto our screens. Click to skip.”